Skip to main content
All insights

What Nvidia Teaches Us About Diversification

This past Friday, I was quoted in Bloomberg News in a story about everyday investors deciding whether to sell/buy/hold their Nvidia stock after Jensen Huang stepped down as CEO.

You can read the full article here.

It was a great conversation, and it touched on something I talk through with clients all the time: how much of your financial future should ride on any one company? Nvidia happens to be a prime example, so I wanted to share a little more about how I think about it.

A great company can still be a bumpy ride

Nvidia has been one of the best investments of the last 25 years. Someone who put $10,000 into NVDA at its 1999 IPO and never touched it would have had about $56 million as of October 23, 2026.1 That’s the story everyone loves to tell.

The part that gets told less often is what it took to get there. Between January and October 2002, the stock lost about 90% of its value, which means it needed roughly a 900% gain just to get back to even.2 This fall it dropped about 35% from its October 6 record in just six weeks.3

One stock vs. thousands, by the numbers

One alternative to betting on one company is a broad index fund. Instead of trying to pick the winners, a broad index fund owns a large slice of the market, often hundreds or thousands of companies, at a very low cost. A few common examples: Vanguard Total Stock Market (VTI) owns nearly every publicly traded US company, Vanguard Growth (VUG) holds large US growth companies, and Vanguard Total International Stock (VXUS) owns thousands of companies outside the US.

Two measures help show the difference between owning one stock and owning a broad index fund. Standard deviation describes how much an investment’s returns have typically varied over a year, so a higher number means a bumpier ride. Max drawdown is the worst drop it has taken from a high point to a low point over the period measured. The table compares three of the largest US companies with three broad index funds.

InvestmentWhat it holdsNumber of holdings4Annualized standard deviation5Max drawdown6Period covered7
Nvidia (NVDA)One company160.4%-89.7%Since IPO (Jan 1999)
Apple (AAPL)One company142.3%-81.8%Since IPO (Dec 1980)
Microsoft (MSFT)One company130.2%-69.4%Since IPO (Mar 1986)
Vanguard Total Stock Market (VTI)Nearly the entire US stock market3,52416.7%-55.4%Since launch (May 2001)
Vanguard Growth (VUG)Large US growth companies13817.7%-50.7%Since launch (Jan 2004)
Vanguard Total International Stock (VXUS)Thousands of companies outside the US8,99515.8%-36.0%Since launch (Jan 2011)

All figures are historical and are not an indication of future results.

Broad index funds aren’t immune to bad years. In the 2008 financial crisis, VTI and VUG each fell by about half, but on average, the regular ebbs and flows of broad index funds have been far less dramatic than those of individual stocks. Another important difference is what happens after a big fall. A broad index fund typically owns both the companies that recover and the companies that replace those that don’t recover. As an example, VUG was back to its previous high about two years after the 2009 bottom.8 A single stock has no built-in way to replace a business that stumbles, unlike a broad index fund.

Further, Arizona State professor Hendrik Bessembinder studied every US stock since 1926 and found that about 58% of them failed to beat one-month Treasury bills (a proxy for low-risk investments) over their lifetimes, while just 4% of stocks accounted for the market’s entire net gain.9 Nvidia, Apple and Microsoft are among those rare winners, which is why their returns look so strong historically. Picking them in advance and holding them through steep drops (upwards of 90% in NVDA’s case), is a very different experience than admiring the long-term return chart today.

How I put this into practice

For the core of a portfolio, I lean on low-cost broad index funds. You give up the dream of owning only the next Nvidia, and in exchange you own the whole market’s long-term growth, which has historically come with far smaller swings than a single stock. VTI has returned about 9.4% a year on average since its 2001 launch,10 and nobody needed to guess which companies were going to win big to get this return.

That doesn’t mean individual stocks are off limits. If you love a company and want to take a swing, go for it! I just suggest keeping any single stock to no more than 5% of your portfolio, and going in prepared for it to fall significantly at some point. At 5%, a 50% drop costs the overall portfolio 2.5%. That stings, but it’s unlikely to change your plans. At 30% of your portfolio, the same drop is a 15% hit to everything you own, and that’s when a bad headline can start moving retirement dates.

Plenty of people end up concentrated without ever choosing to, through company stock or one investment that simply grew. When that’s the case, we build a plan to bring it down over time tax-efficiently, with the goal of keeping the fix from creating a big tax bill of its own.

If you’d like to talk through your own portfolio, or a position you’ve been meaning to deal with, click the Contact Us button in the top right to book an intro call. I’d love to chat!

Notes and disclosure

This post is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. All performance and risk figures are historical and are not an indication of future results. Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against loss, and all investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

1 YCharts, Growth of $10,000 in NVDA from its January 22, 1999 IPO through October 23, 2026, with dividends reinvested.

2 YCharts, NVDA’s worst total-return drawdown, from its January 3, 2002 peak to its October 9, 2002 low.

3 YCharts, NVDA closing price decline from its October 6, 2026 record close to November 17, 2026.

4 YCharts, data as of 11/17/2026. Number of holdings reported for each fund. Each stock is a single company.

5 YCharts, data as of 11/17/2026. Annualized standard deviation of monthly returns, from each stock’s IPO or each fund’s launch.

6 YCharts, data as of 11/17/2026. Maximum drawdown since inception: the largest decline from a peak to a later low, from each stock’s IPO or each fund’s launch.

7 YCharts, data as of 11/17/2026. Stocks are measured from their IPO and funds from their launch, so periods differ: NVDA about 27.8 years, VTI about 25 years, VUG about 22 years and VXUS about 15 years. AAPL and MSFT are measured from their 1980 and 1986 IPOs.

8 YCharts, VUG drawdown ending March 9, 2009, with recovery to its prior high taking 485 trading sessions.

9 Hendrik Bessembinder, “Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills?” Journal of Financial Economics, 2018, covering US stocks from 1926 to 2016: ASU W. P. Carey.

10 YCharts, data as of 11/17/2026. VTI annualized total return since its May 2001 launch, calculated from daily data with dividends reinvested.

Start the conversation

Let’s find your path to higher ground.

A first conversation is simply a chance to see if working together feels right.

Book an Intro